Witcher 3 Open Sesame Best Choices And Quest Outcomes

The Hearts of Stone expansion for The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt introduces players to some of the most intricate and narrative-driven quests in the entire RPG genre. Among these, the multi-stage mission titled Open Sesame stands out due to its high-stakes heist structure and complex moral dilemmas. Players must navigate family feuds, choose a specialized crew, and ultimately decide the fate of a massive fortune while fulfilling Olgierd von Everec's second wish.

The Core Conflict Between the Borsodi Brothers

As Geralt infiltrates the highly secured vault beneath the auction house, he is caught directly in the middle of a bitter sibling rivalry between Horst and Ewald Borsodi. Horst represents the established establishment, maintaining absolute control over the family fortune while showing little regard for those he considers beneath him. On the other hand, Ewald is the vengeful outcast who orchestrates the entire robbery to reclaim his birthright and ruin his brother.

When the dramatic confrontation occurs inside the vault, players are forced to align with one of the brothers, a decision that drastically alters the narrative flow of the heist. Siding with Ewald leads to a direct battle against Horst and his guards, resulting in Horst's death at the hands of his brother. Conversely, backing Horst forces Geralt to eliminate Ewald, preserving Horst's status as the master of the auction house.

Evaluating the Ultimate Vault Rewards and Outcomes

Regardless of which brother you choose to support during the final standoff, the primary objective remains securing the House of Maximilian Borsodi to satisfy Olgierd's contract. However, the fate of the valuable property deeds inside the box depends entirely on your subsequent dialogue choices and negotiation skills. Players can choose to leave the documents behind, allowing the surviving brother to retain the legal rights to the family wealth.

Alternatively, Geralt can demand the documents by force or through strategic compromise, which often triggers an additional skirmish inside the burning vault rooms. For completionists, the best strategic outcome involves siding with Ewald but negotiating peacefully for the box while letting him keep the papers inside. This nuanced resolution satisfies the contractual requirements of the main storyline while minimizing unnecessary bloodshed among the companions.

Long Term Impacts on Character Affiliations

The choices made deep within the subterranean facility do not heavily impact the overarching political landscape of Velen, but they do change how certain characters perceive Geralt. Leaving the property deeds with the surviving brother triggers a unique and highly thematic dialogue sequence when returning to Olgierd. It showcases Geralt's professionalism as a Witcher who focuses purely on fulfilling contracts rather than meddling in noble inheritance laws.

Additionally, your choice of crew members during the preparation phase influences how smoothly the initial break-in unfolds before the final brotherly dispute. Selecting the right combination of safecracking specialists and infiltration experts alters the tactical gameplay elements leading up to the vault confrontation. Balancing these early structural components ensures a highly efficient run through one of the expansion's most memorable set pieces.